Claims and payers

Reading the reason codes on a dental ERA

Every line an insurance company adjusts on a dental ERA or EOB carries up to three codes: a group code that says who owes the difference (CO, PR, OA or PI), a claim adjustment reason code (a number such as 45 or 29) that says why, and sometimes a remark code (such as N30) that adds detail. Read the group first. CO is a write off under your contract, PR is the patient's share to bill, and OA and PI need a closer look before anyone writes anything off.

Three layers on every adjusted line

An electronic remittance (the 835 file your clearinghouse turns into an ERA) and most printed EOBs explain every dollar the payer did not pay with the same standard codes. They come in three layers, and offices that read only the number usually misread the line.

Group code
Two letters that say who carries the amount: CO, PR, OA or PI. This decides whether the money is written off, billed to the patient or looked at again.
Reason code (CARC)
A number that says why the line was adjusted: 1 for a deductible, 45 for the fee schedule, 29 for a late claim. The same number can mean a write off under one group and a patient balance under another.
Remark code (RARC)
An optional code starting with N, M or MA that adds detail, such as which piece of information was missing. When the reason code says something is missing, the remark code usually names it.

The four group codes

CO: contractual obligation
The write off your contract with this payer requires. It is not billable to the patient. CO 45, a charge above the allowed amount on the fee schedule, is the one you will see on almost every in network claim.
PR: patient responsibility
The amount the patient owes: a deductible, coinsurance, a copay, or a service the plan does not cover. This is the amount to bill.
OA: other adjustment
Neither a contractual write off nor a patient balance. Usually a transfer to another payer or a bookkeeping entry, and it deserves a look before it is written off.
PI: payer initiated reduction
The payer's own policy reduced the line, not your contract. These are the reductions most often worth reviewing or appealing.

The codes a patient owes

Under PR, three numbers make up most patient balances on a line the plan did pay. They are not denials: the plan worked as written, and the amount moves to the patient.

  • PR 1: applied to the patient's deductible.
  • PR 2: coinsurance, the patient's percentage share.
  • PR 3: a copay, the patient's flat amount for the visit.
  • PR 204 or PR 96: a service the current plan does not cover. Usually billable to the patient, but confirm against your contract first.

Denials you fix and send again

These are office side reasons: the claim met the wrong plan, the wrong person or a missing field. A corrected claim usually gets an answer, which is why they are worth working first.

26, 27, 31
The service was before the coverage started (26) or after it ended (27), or the payer cannot find the patient as insured (31). Check the insurance on file and resend the claim.
109
Not covered by this payer. Send the claim to the correct payer or plan.
22
This care may be covered by another plan under coordination of benefits. Send it to the other plan first, then send this plan the first plan's answer.
16
The claim is missing information or has a submission error. Look for the remark code on the same line: it names the exact field to fix before you resend.

The coordination of benefits case has its own guide: denied for coordination of benefits, and how to unpick it.

Codes that need a person, not a resend

  • 18, a duplicate: the payer already has this claim. Do not send it again; find the answer to the first claim.
  • 29, timely filing: the claim reached the payer after its deadline. Find your proof it was sent on time, usually the clearinghouse acceptance report, and appeal with it. The timely filing guide walks through it.
  • 97, bundled: the payer counts this service as part of another one it already paid. Read the pair before deciding whether to appeal.
  • 151, frequency: the plan allows the service only so often, for example a second cleaning too soon. Usually the plan working as written.
  • 119, a benefit maximum: the annual or lifetime maximum has been reached for the period.
  • 50, medical necessity: the payer judged the service not necessary. Appeal with x rays, chart notes and a narrative if you disagree.

For the wider picture of which denials are your office's to fix and which are the plan's design, read why dental claims get denied.

The short version

  • Read the group code before the number: CO is the contract's write off, PR is the patient's share, OA and PI need a person's look.
  • CO 45 is the ordinary contractual write off, the difference between your fee and the plan's allowed amount, and it is never billed to the patient.
  • PR 1, PR 2 and PR 3 are the deductible, coinsurance and copay: the amounts a patient owes on a line the plan did pay.
  • Eligibility denials (26, 27, 31) and wrong plan denials (109, 22) are fixed by checking the insurance on file and sending the claim to the right plan.
  • A duplicate (18) is never sent again: the payer already has the first claim, and the answer to that one is what to look for.

Where this sits in Practice Evolved

Practice Evolved reads the remittances from the clearinghouse portal your office already uses and shows denial patterns and payer scorecards for Eaglesoft and Open Dental practices, so a pattern by reason or by payer shows without anyone building a spreadsheet.

Opens our demo practice. No account, no signup, real working screens.

Free revenue leak audit

What is insurance still holding?

We read your own claims and send back one page about them.

What is insurance still holding?

The report carries totals for your practice. No patient names, ever.